After the viewing of the video messages, a controversy surrounding one of the couples begins to stir Temptation Island. Ytossie is so upset by Taheed's silence that she confides her sorrows to Greg (Naval Flight Instructor). As they stroll along the beach arm in arm, she cries on his shoulder and shares some painful information: she and Taheed have a year-and-a-half-old baby together. She knows the camera is following them and the guys behind the camera are employees of Fox. Shortly thereafter, a water taxi approaches Mata Chica as Mandy explains that the cast has noticed the unsettling appearance of show producer Chris at the resort. Mandy: "This morning after viewing tapes we saw Chris, one of the producers, and we thought it was very fishy because we don't talk to the producers at all, we're not supposed to, we're not allowed to. The fact that Chris is here, we're freaking out, my heart was racing, we're all looking at each other like, something's about to go down." Taheed arrives to the girls retreat by boat and sees Ytossie standing outside her bungalow. She asked him to go in and he saw Chris, the executive producer. Chris greets Taheed and then tells them both, "The time that you guys have had here, I know has been emotional and exhilarating. That was expected. Unexpectedly however, some information has come up that is problematic. We now know that you guys have a child together. And I think that's a very dangerous scenario for the show. My responsibility as a producer, Fox's responsibility as a broadcast network was never to put a mother and father of a child into a situation where they'd be tempted into potentially fracturing that relationship. It would just kill me to think that the experience could potentially drive a child's parents apart. It's totally different for two singles who are trying to decide whether or not they want to start a family, and as a result of that I've gotta pull you guys from the mix. I cannot allow you guys to date any longer. That's the way things have got to be." Chris offers them another suite at another location to try to talk and mend fences. He says the choice is theirs, but if they do choose to take his offer the show will check in with them to see how they're doing. Taheed said that he did not really care anymore and left it up to Ytossie to make the choice and she decide to take the suite and try to work on things. Chris said they have a boat standing by, and they need to get packed up. They were allowed to say goodbye to whoever they want to on the island. Taheed tells the other guys that he doesn't believe two people should stay together just because they have a child together, but he assures them he will take care of his responsibilities. The girls tell Ytossie that it is for the better because now they are forced to talk about the situation. Kaya believes that the child is a large enough motivating factor for them to "patch it up" and stay together. Surprisingly his girlfriend Valerie is more philosophical, believing "If you remain in a relationship with someone that you're not happy with, then you are preventing the person from coming into your life that you are supposed to be with."

Shannon and Mandy decide to give Valerie the choice of either Johnny or Jon. Valerie chooses Jon. Valerie and Shannon set up Mandy with either Greg or Tom. Mandy selects Tom. Mandy and Valerie decide that Shannon can have either Dano or Jim. Though her boyfriend Andy predicts she will take out Jim, she startles him when she chooses speed demon, Dano.

It's the guys' turn next. Billy and Andy select Elizabeth or LaWonna for Kaya. When he decides on LaWonna, Valerie glares at her boyfriend suspiciously. Mark asks Valerie how she's doing, and she laughs uncomfortably, choking on her response, "I'm….I'm good." She lets out a big sigh. Andy and Kaya offer Billy an ironic choice of Megan (Andy's first blind date) or Alison (Kaya's first blind date). Billy selects Megan. Mandy's date Tom notices that Billy grabs Megan's hand as she passes in front of him. He wins praises from Mandy when he asks if she's all right. At this moment, Mandy explains, "Tom rose above Billy by respecting me. And I'm not Tom's girlfriend. I'm Billy's girlfriend." Kaya and Billy hook up Andy with either Venus or Vanessa. Andy tries to show Shannon and all the rest that he really is a nice guy when he shouts to Venus "Venus, have you been on a date yet?" When she answers no, he picks her. Shannon gushes, "Andy gets better and better as this trip goes on. His selfless rationale shined through and made me want to run over there and jump him." It's a good thing Andy has Shannon because he scores a big zero with Venus who laments that Andy's choice makes her look like a "pity date."

The following evening arrives, and so does the suspenseful bonfire. The coupled men travel to meet Mark first. Tonight he gives the guys the opportunity to remove all the dating blocks for their girlfriends. However, this is not choice each individual gets to make. This can only happen by a majority vote. Andy is reluctant. He speculates that Shannon will read the situation as "reverse psychology." He also warns his buddies that the dates are most likely "going to get way more intense. Waay more intense." In spite of the risks, the guys unanimously vote in favor of tossing all the dating blocks. Next, they are given the chance to watch video snippets of after-hours activities at their girlfriends' resort (these are activities with the singles that don't occur during dates). Tonight the guy's choice does not impact his girlfriend's choice, so if Kaya watches a tape, Valerie can still elect not to watch. Mark reads the tape titles : "Flesh Parade", "Jacuzzi Jump" and "Make him do Anything I Want". The random titles do not indicate which girlfriend is featured on which tape. So if Billy elects to watch a tape, there's no guarantee it will feature Mandy -- he might see Valerie or Shannon instead. And if, for example, he decides not to watch a tape, he might deprive Andy of seeing Shannon. Since the guys have always watched each other's tapes together, the choice is all or nothing by default. Kaya goes first. Handing the decision to fate, Kaya asks Mark to shuffle the tapes, and then he grabs one. It's "Flesh Parade," which is part of the "costume" pageant that the single guys performed for the ladies on the beach. The clip features Sean, the massage therapist, seemingly flashing the girls. Ironically, Billy dismisses the viewing experience as "painless," while Andy remarks on how much their ladies seemed to enjoy it. Next, Andy selects "Make Him do Anything I Want," which features Shannon in a hot tub with Sean. She brags that she is wearing Sean's two blocking bracelets, so he is going to have to do anything she wants him to do in order to get them back from her. Sean points out the massage table is "right over there." Andy looks over at the tape and says "my girlfriend is totally hammered here", they all laugh Kaya goes last, and they all see "Jacuzzi Jump." This time Valerie and Charlie stand on the edge of the hot tub while Mandy, Shannon and the singles chant their names encouraging them to jump in together. The crowd goes wild as Valerie begins to remove her pants and reveals her thong. Chickening out, she decides to leap in with her pants on. In Mark's presence, the guys appear content with the fact that the ladies are having a good time as they have encouraged them to do.  As the bonfire winds down, Mark announces there will be no opportunity to communicate with video messages tonight. Before they leave, he mentions that there are two more dates to go -- one date tomorrow and then the final date. The final date will be a special, romantic experience; However, Mark explains, "You can only go on that date with somebody you've already dated."

Mandy, Valerie, and Shannon arrive at the bonfire. They accept their boyfriends' challenge and unanimously agree to lift the dating blocks for the fellows. When Mark describes the option to watch video clips of the late night fun at their boyfriends' resort, the ladies are suspicious, but their expressions appear a little mischievous tonight. Mark reads the titles, "Sex Advice," "Striptease," and "Hammock Ride." Before he can finish reading, Valerie whispers to her friends, "We're watching the tapes," and Mandy agrees, "Let's watch it." Having immediate second thoughts, Valerie begs off and makes Shannon choose first. Shannon resists, telling Mark that she feels peer pressure to watch. In the end, Shannon selects what sounds like a harmless tape, "Sex Advice." The three women bicker about what they've embarked on with this choice, but now it's too late. They watch a clip where Andy, Kaya, and Taheed bash Mandy for doing the body shot with Johnny. They hope that Billy seeks revenge with Vanessa the cowgirl because, as Kaya whoops, "It's time for the rodeo!" Valerie and Shannon are clueless, but Mandy knows what this conversation is all about. She suspects that Billy has sought revenge for her actions with a girl that he likes. Without even a pause, Mandy's anger makes her bold and she demands, "I want to see another one." She selects "Striptease." Unfortunately, the clip is about Billy again. Mandy watches him perform the sexy pseudo striptease in the bar for Vanessa and the single girls.

The End